Search
Covered porch framed by cedar posts, looking toward stone terrace steps and a wooded slope.

Harrison Lake Already Lived the Renovation Story Otter Creek Is Starting Now

Last month, players from the LPGA Legends Tour walked the fairways at Harrison Lake Country Club for the first time. The 2026 LPGA Legends Championship ran August 13 through 15, and the course that hosted it was not the same course Columbus golfers played a decade ago. It was rebuilt from the ground up between 2021 and 2022 by golf course architect Tim Liddy, and the redesign was good enough to earn an honorable mention in Golf Inc.'s International Renovation of the Year Awards, with credit going to Liddy, Wadsworth Construction, Joe Titzer, Dave Axland, and the HLCC grounds crew who have kept it in tournament shape since.

That timing matters more than it looks. Harrison Lake completed a full course rebuild before hosting a professional championship on the other side of it. And a few miles east, another Columbus golf institution just started the same process. If you belong to HLCC, or you live inside the gates and have seen what that rebuild made possible, you already have a preview of what the next few years at Otter Creek Golf Course are going to feel like.

A Renovation With Receipts

Harrison Lake Country Club has been the only private club Columbus has had since 1945. It went through a round of additions in 1998, but the more consequential work came recently: a full redesign of the short game area, a relocated driving range, and reconstruction of all eighteen holes, with the course reopening in August 2022. That is not a facelift. That is the kind of rebuild that closes holes for a season, reroutes carts around construction fencing, and tests a membership's patience before it pays off.

It paid off. The Golf Inc. honorable mention put Harrison Lake in the same conversation as the country's better-known private club renovations, and this August the LPGA Legends Tour chose the course for its season-ending championship, including a free youth clinic at the driving range with LPGA professionals and open access to watch tournament play. That is the kind of validation a membership feels directly. You do not need to have played in the pro-am to notice that your home course just hosted a national tour stop.

The Same Name, A Few Miles Down The Road

Here is the connection that most write-ups of either project miss. Bob Haddad Jr., who helped carry forward his father's work at Harrison Lake Country Club, is the same person now leading the transformation of Otter Creek Golf Course. He and a local ownership group purchased Otter Creek from the City of Columbus in 2022, the same year Harrison Lake's own rebuild reopened.

Otter Creek is not a random public course. It opened in 1964 on land and funding provided by Cummins and its longtime leader J. Irwin Miller, designed by Robert Trent Jones Sr. in a clubhouse designed by architect Harry Weese, tying it directly into Columbus's better-known architectural legacy. The course hosted the Indiana State Amateur from 1965 through 1990 and picked it up again in later years, along with the 1991 U.S. Amateur Public Links Championship. It has been sitting on that pedigree for six decades. Haddad's group is now spending real money to make sure it earns a new one.

What Otter Creek Is Actually Building

The renovation, branded the "New Otter," is not a simple re-grassing. According to reporting from AmateurGolf.com, the plan includes three distinct playing experiences:

  • The New Otter — an 18-hole championship course designed with the ambition of hosting a future USGA championship, including a hole modeled on the Postage Stamp at Royal Troon and design cues borrowed from the Road Hole at St Andrews
  • The Pup — a 12-hole putting-and-chipping course
  • The Romp — a 13-hole traditional par-3 layout

A 20,000-square-foot putting green is planned directly behind the clubhouse, positioned to overlook both the opening tee shot on No. 1 and the closing green on No. 18. The historic outdoor scoreboard, one of the most recognizable pieces of the original property, is expected to stay exactly where it is. Inside, the clubhouse still carries its 1960s character: green carpeting, a brick-backed bar, slatted wood walls. Haddad's group is not trying to erase Otter Creek's identity. They are trying to build a better version of the same course, the way Harrison Lake did.

The Calendar Worth Watching If You Belong To HLCC

For Harrison Lake members, this is not abstract news about a course across town. Membership already includes play packages at Otter Creek, so the renovation timeline is effectively part of your own club calendar for the next two years.

The new practice range and chipping facilities are scheduled to open in late summer 2026, which puts them opening right about now. The Pup and The Romp are projected for spring 2027. The New Otter itself, including three newly constructed holes, is targeted for fall 2027. In the meantime, the former 27-hole configuration is closed while construction continues, which means anyone counting on a quick nine at Otter Creek this fall will need to plan around it.

If that sounds familiar, it should. Harrison Lake went through its own version of this exact sequence: partial closures, a redesigned short game area, a relocated range, a full season of construction dust before the course reopened in August 2022. Members who stuck through that know the emotional arc already. The frustration of a closed hole in year one gives way to a course you are proud to have host a tour event in year four. Otter Creek is at the very beginning of that same arc.

What This Looks Like From The Clubhouse

None of this has slowed down what Harrison Lake Country Club actually does on a Tuesday. The kitchen still rotates a new menu weekly, running from Wednesday's dinner service through the following Wednesday's lunch, with a themed buffet once a month and a Sunday brunch, also once a month, from 10:30 a.m. to 1:30 p.m. A recent ladies' luncheon put out butternut squash and harvest quiche with a fall fennel salad, the kind of seasonal menu that shows up on the club's own social feed more than in any press release. The club also finished building a new grounds maintenance facility this year, which sounds like an administrative detail until you remember it is the building responsible for keeping a Tim Liddy redesign, and now a tour-ready course, in the condition that earns awards and hosts championships.

That is the actual state of golf life at Harrison Lake right now. One course finished its transformation and got validated by a national tour. Another course, built by the same hands and inspired by two of golf's most famous holes, just started its own. If you are a member watching Otter Creek's construction fencing go up this fall, you are not watching a stranger's project. You are watching the same playbook Harrison Lake already ran, with a longer runway and a bigger ambition.

If you are weighing a move to lake life anywhere in Bartholomew County, or you already call Harrison Lake home and want a conversation about what is happening on the water and on the fairways around it, Christopher Braun is always glad to talk through it, golf included.

Follow Us On Instagram