In 1945, two separate projects began on the farmland west of Columbus. One was Harrison Lake Country Club. The Republic has recounted that the club was founded that year on land from the Herman Bense farm and opened its first nine holes in 1947. The other was Q. G. Noblitt's Harrison Lake Development. According to a local history account drawn from an Indiana State Library aerial caption, its lots were sold from the surrounding farmland, and heavy rains in January 1949 filled the dug basin.
Eight decades later the lake and the club still read as one place, and the club calls its course integral to the surrounding neighborhood. Membership is still its own step. It begins with an inquiry to the club, the same way it does for anyone in Columbus. For a buyer looking at homes along the lake, the more useful question is which of the club's memberships fits the way the household will actually use the year. The club's 2026-27 menu is organized around that question, and the golf behind it is about to grow.
A Menu Built Around How You Spend the Year
The 2026-27 membership packet, dated February 13, 2026, is titled "Memberships For Every Season Of Life." Some tiers are organized by activity. Others are written for households that divide the year between Columbus and somewhere else.
| Tier | Written for | What the packet describes |
|---|---|---|
| Premier | Families wanting every amenity | Dining, golf, pool, tennis and pickleball |
| Harrison | Premier families who want more convenience | Premier plus a family cart pass and an indoor practice studio pass |
| Snowbird (Premier) | Those who winter in warmer climates | Premier privileges April 1 through December 31; inactive January through March |
| Non-Resident (Premier) | Non-residents and "those who summer at the lake" | Access to all the club's amenities |
| Masters | Golfers who want to practice and play as much as possible | Golf plus the indoor simulator studio; pool as a plug-in; no tennis |
| Dine & Links | Busy singles, couples and young families | 40 prepaid nine-hole rounds a year, outdoor practice and dining |
| Non-Resident Dine & Links | Golfers who live 20 or more miles away and have a home course elsewhere | 40 prepaid nine-hole rounds a year with range warm-up |
| Dine & Volley | Court sports players | Three lighted tennis courts, four pickleball courts, optional golf and pool |
| Social | Dining first | Dining and member events, optional golf and pool |
The Snowbird and Non-Resident Premier tiers carry the full Premier experience to households that are not in Columbus all year. One is written for people who leave for the winter, the other for people who come to the lake for the summer. A buyer weighing a second home at Harrison Lake against one on another Columbus-area lake will find that the club already has tiers for part-year members.
The menu also reaches past golf. The Seasonal Pool membership is pool-only, with certified lifeguards, a gated wading pool for toddlers and a full-service snack shop. The Junior Development membership is for advanced junior golfers aged 14 to 18 or younger qualifying juniors, and parents need at least a Social membership. Corporate memberships are built case by case.
The Clubhouse in the Cold Months
A buyer touring Harrison Lake this winter will find the club in its indoor season. Every tier except Seasonal Pool includes the dining rooms, the Lakeview Room and the Harrison Grill, along with invitations to member social events. The packet says the renovated interior was unveiled in April 2025. Members get a 50% discount on room fees for events in the banquet rooms, a useful perk for a household hosting its first holiday gathering on the lake.
The club is officially open year-round. Its FAQ describes a winter "slowdown" of two to three weeks, typically from Christmas through the second week of January, when operations are limited and staff take on facility projects. Nonmembers can sometimes get a table too. The club often opens a limited number of reservations to the public for occasions such as Valentine's Day and New Year's Eve, which gives a buyer who is still deciding an easy way to see the dining room.
The club does not publish membership prices. Its FAQ says costs vary by membership and that "modest initiation fees apply." The one per-round price printed on the 2026-27 form is $30 for each optional prepaid nine-hole round for Social and Dine & Volley members, with cart fees on top. Treat these figures as general information, not financial advice, and confirm current pricing with the club. The membership office is at 812-342-4457, extension 103, and staff there can schedule a club visit, a dinner reservation or a round of golf.
Otter Creek Is Coming Back in Stages
The Premier and Masters descriptions list "future access to Otter Creek" among golf inclusions, and Dine & Links lists "limited future access." The two courses share leadership. The Republic reported in 2022 that Otter Creek's sale to Architerra had closed, with Bob Haddad Jr., then Harrison Lake's chief operating officer, as its registered agent. Austin Wright is now director of golf at both.
In September 2026, The Republic reported that Haddad hoped contractors would finish by Thanksgiving, with grow-in to follow. He said the 12-hole Pup course could open in middle-to-late summer 2027, part of the Romp course and the driving range could open sooner, and the full Otter course likely would not be ready until mid-to-late 2028. While Otter Creek is closed, Golf Columbus lists Harrison Lake as its 2026 golf option. A buyer comparing Masters with Dine & Links today is comparing golf at one course, with a second course coming over the next two seasons.
Harrison Lake's own course had a national stage this year. In August 2026 it hosted the LPGA Legends Championship, which Maria McBride won by one stroke over Angela Stanford.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the club host events for nonmembers? Yes. The FAQ says the club hosts hundreds of personal and corporate events each year, including weddings.
Do tennis and pickleball players need Premier? No. Dine & Volley includes the three lighted tennis courts and four pickleball courts, with golf and pool as optional add-ons.
If a Harrison Lake home near the club is on your list, Christopher Braun would be glad to show you the neighborhood this winter. Visit the Harrison Lake neighborhood page or schedule a private tour or consultation.