Search
Timber-framed covered entry with a glazed wood door, limestone steps, and oakleaf hydrangeas beside a raised stone border.

Two Kitchens, One Old Church Lot: How The Property in Ogilville Actually Works

The Property, a dining spot at 9250 S. State Road 58 in Ohio Township, opened this year. It is two businesses on one country parcel, and they run on different rules. The Church serves dinner in the former Ogilville United Methodist Church. You need a reservation, and seatings are set times. The Annex Café & Market sits behind it in a 1960 auxiliary building, and you can walk in any day of the week. Most of the attention goes to the church. The café was the original plan, though, and its developer wrote that she wanted it to serve as a community space.

That order matters if you're planning a visit. Here's how the two halves differ, how they came to share a lot, and what's on the calendar this fall.

The Same Address, Two Different Evenings

The Church serves dinner Wednesday through Saturday, by reservation only. Seatings are at 5:30, 7:00 and 8:30 PM. Weekday dinners are à la carte. On weekends the dining room switches to a five-course tasting menu. The Annex keeps longer hours: 7 AM to 9 PM on weekdays and 9 AM to 9 PM on weekends. The kitchen stops serving freshly made food from 2 to 4 PM, but the bar and market stay open.

The Church The Annex Café & Market
Building Former Ogilville United Methodist Church, built 1904 Auxiliary building dating to 1960, expanded
Days Wednesday through Saturday, dinner Seven days
Hours Seatings at 5:30, 7:00 and 8:30 PM 7 AM to 9 PM weekdays, 9 AM to 9 PM weekends
How you get in Reservation only Walk in
Format À la carte weekdays, five-course tasting weekends Café counter, market, self-pour beer wall
Quiet window None posted Kitchen pauses 2 to 4 PM

The menus are different too. The Church's current menu, posted September 29, 2026, lists a chilled seafood platter, scallops, beef-cheek pasta and Indiana beef cuts including ribeye and filet. The tasting menu is $125 per person. The Annex menu is everyday food: avocado toast, poached eggs, pumpkin waffles, a breakfast panini, fried green beans, wings, corn ribs, gelato and the Annex steak sandwich. When The Property announced the Annex's opening, it also promised baked goods, deli items and a self-pour wall of regional craft beer.

So you can have breakfast or a weekday lunch here on short notice. A tasting-menu Saturday takes planning ahead.

The Café Came First

The current setup comes from a project that changed shape partway through.

  1. By 1937, the church shows up in county aerial imagery. A house was built on the site in 1940 and later torn down. The auxiliary building that now holds the Annex dates to 1960.
  2. October 23, 2023: The Bartholomew County Board of Zoning Appeals approved a use variance for a café in Ogilville, according to The Republic. At that point the plan covered only the auxiliary building.
  3. May 29, 2024: The board voted unanimously to approve a larger variance that added the church building. The Republic reported that developer Cari Roberts decided it made more sense to renovate both buildings at once than to finish the church later as a second phase.
  4. February 2026: The Property's own updates showed framing up at the Annex and arched-ceiling framing and exterior work at the church, with interior finishing and mechanical work still to come.
  5. July 30, 2026: The Property set the Annex grand opening for Wednesday, August 19, with doors opening at 6:00 AM.

The bigger plan also ran into the physical limits of a rural site. The 2024 plan expanded the Annex building by 2,227 square feet to make room for a bigger kitchen. The parcel also grew from 1.55 acres to 9.71 acres through an administrative subdivision. According to the county planning staff report, the extra land was needed for a required septic system. The land is zoned agriculture: general rural, which is why each phase needed a variance before any food could be served.

What the Annex Was Meant to Be

The Annex keeps longer hours and takes walk-ins because that was the plan from the start. In a memo to the planning department, quoted by The Republic, Roberts described it this way:

"I see the property used as a community space, a place where people have meetings or go to work away from the house."

The same memo promised free wifi for anyone. On food, Roberts wrote, "We'll be offering small bites in the morning/afternoon, lots of healthy foods for grab-and-go customers, craft coffee, and teas," and added, "I see it evolving as we see what the community desires." The 2024 filing proposed café hours of 6 AM to 10 PM. The posted schedule now runs 7 AM to 9 PM on weekdays, so early risers should go by the posted hours.

The 2024 plan also included a dog park, fire pits and a children's area. The current Visit Columbus listing describes outdoor space for families, live music and ticketed events. Call ahead if you're counting on a particular feature for a particular day.

What the Church Was Meant to Be

The church was always meant to be the dressier half. When the board approved it, The Republic reported that Roberts planned to serve steak, seafood and pasta with a "speakeasy" feel. She described it as having the atmosphere of a "Henry Social Club" with a "Story Inn" type of quaintness. She called the building a "treasure trove of historical value" and said she wanted to preserve and "revitalize" it. Back in 2023, The Republic had reported that she hoped to keep the church as an important local landmark, before it was even part of the restaurant plan.

The menu posted now sticks close to that plan, with steak, seafood and pasta all on it. County planning records put the church building at 3,488 square feet.

The Backyard Calendar This Fall

The two halves come together outdoors. The Property lists live music in The Property Backyard on two upcoming Saturdays:

  • Saturday, October 31: Michael Kelsey Band, 6 to 9 PM
  • Saturday, November 7: Phil Pierle & Company, 6 to 9 PM

Both shows overlap with all three Church seatings. If you want dinner and the music on the same night, book the table first. The Annex bar and market stay open until 9 PM on weekends, so the walk-in side covers the whole show.

The Property also takes inquiries for weddings, receptions, rehearsal dinners, private dinners, corporate events and outdoor gatherings. Its event-space page still reads "Opening in Spring 2026," so ask the venue directly about dates and capacity before you plan around it.

Finding It

The Republic's coverage of the county zoning approval gives the address as 9250 S. State Road 58 in Ohio Township. Visit Columbus lists the Annex at that address with a Columbus mailing line. It lists The Church as 9250 E SR 58, Ogilville. Both refer to the same lot, so if one version gives your map app trouble, try the other.

For a weekday visit, the Annex is ready at 7 AM. Before 2 PM you get the full kitchen menu, and after 4 PM it starts again. For a Friday or Saturday, the Church's five-course tasting menu at $125 per person is what to reserve ahead.

For a rural parcel like this one, the zoning variances, septic requirements and two-phase plans count as much as the old building does. If you're curious about property in southern Bartholomew County, Grandview Lake Property can walk you through how projects like The Property get approved. Schedule a private tour or consultation with Chris Braun.

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.

Follow Us On Instagram